In March 2024, the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) revealed it had removed 239 companies, including Microsoft, Procter & Gamble, Unilever and Walmart, from the list of those committed to setting net-zero targets. The companies had timed out: SBTi rules give businesses 24 months to submit targets for validation after the initiative finalizes a standard or receives a commitment, and the companies missed the deadline.
Trellis reached out to SBTi and several companies that had commitments removed to understand what happened next. Here’s what we discovered.
Very few subsequently had targets validated
According to SBTi data, as of last week just 17 of the 239 companies have had net-zero targets validated since their commitments were removed. The list includes British American Tobacco, Gap and S&P Global.
The remaining 222 companies — 93 percent of those that had commitments removed — includes many large businesses, from the large French utility EDF to JBS, one of the food giant, together with United Airlines, Johnson & Johnson and Unilever. (Some of these companies may be in the process of having net-zero targets validated. SBTi does not comment on targets that are being assessed.)
It’s worth noting that SBTi offers companies the option of committing only to a near-term target, which is often set for 2030. Of the 239 companies that had commitments removed, 14 subsequently had near-term targets validated, including Unilever and Johnson & Johnson. Many of the others, including Microsoft, Walmart, United and EDF, already had near-term targets validated.
Looking across the economy as a whole, slightly more than 1,900 companies have had net-zero targets validated by SBTi and close to 2,900 have committed to doing so.
Companies are exploring other options
Trellis reached out to 10 of the companies that have not subsequently had net-zero targets validated for updates on their strategy. The majority — Carrefour, Procter & Gamble (P&G), United, JBS, Elevance Health (formerly known as Anthem), Engie and Johnson & Johnson — did not return our inquiries.
The replies we did receive, together with press releases from companies on our list, reveal that some companies are exploring other options for guiding their net-zero journeys.
Unilever, for instance, said it remains committed to reaching net zero by 2039 — more than a decade ahead of many other companies. A company spokesperson said the plan “aligns with the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s definition of net zero, which differs from the SBTi’s definition,” but did not return a follow-up request for clarification on how Unilever interprets the difference.
Carrefour, a retailer with more than 14,000 stores in 40 countries, has since had the interim targets in its transition plan validated as in line with 1.5 degrees Celsius of warming by the ACT Initiative, a standard originally developed by the French government and now hosted by the World Benchmarking Alliance. Carrefour has begun using the methodology to assess the plans of its suppliers in its home country of France.