Discovering the Ultimate Imitation Samoas
Every year, Girl Scout Cookie enthusiasts eagerly anticipate the return of favorites like Thin Mints and Tagalongs, but nothing quite compares to the delectable Samoas. Fortunately, we’ve unearthed year-round alternatives that come close to matching the original taste.
Our team of specialists meticulously curates every item we showcase. By making a purchase through our links, you may give us a small commission.
MOLLY ALLEN FOR TASTE OF HOME
When Girl Scout Cookie season arrives, thoughts immediately turn to the iconic treats like Thin Mints, Tagalongs, and, most notably, Samoas. While crafting homemade Girl Scout cookie replicas is enjoyable, the convenience of store-bought counterparts can often be quite tempting.
Since the 1970s, Samoas, also known as Caramel deLites in certain regions, have been a beloved treat in many households. However, when Girl Scouts are not out taking orders, locating these cookies becomes a challenge. To help aficionados satisfy their cravings for chocolate, caramel, and coconut, we subjected various store-bought copycat Samoas to rigorous taste tests.
Below are the brands that underwent our examination, ranging from the original to the competitors:
- Benton’s by Aldi
- Crav’n
- Girl Scouts
- Keebler
- Safeway Signature Select
1 / 6
MOLLY ALLEN FOR TASTE OF HOME
Our Copycat Samoas Evaluation Process
In our quest for the finest Samoa cookies, we acquired both a box of original Samoa Girl Scout Cookies and four imitation versions. (Similar assessments have been conducted with top-notch grocery store cakes.)
The objective of this taste analysis was to identify a treat that surpassed or equaled the beloved Samoas peddled by Girl Scouts. Our criteria called for a round treat with a crisp shortbread cookie base, a generous amount of gooey caramel, flaked coconut, and a hint of chocolate to tie it all together.
2 / 6
Molly Allen for Taste of Home
Safeway Signature Select Caramel Coconut Fudge Cookies
This particular option is typically available at Safeway and many Albertsons outlets. While the appearance of these cookies closely resembled both Benton’s and Crav’n offerings, the taste and texture failed to deliver the same impact. Although the flavor was acceptable, this caramel coconut fudge delight lacked harmony. The cookie featured an overly thick shortbread center, with an insufficient amount of caramel or fudge to create a harmonious blend.
In conclusion, while not unappealing, the cookie-to-caramel-to-fudge ratio was inadequate, preventing this Samoa imitator from standing out.
3 / 6
Molly Allen for Taste of Home
Keebler Coconut Dreams
Surprisingly, Keebler’s version did not receive as high a ranking as expected. While it did feature a commendable amount of fudge on both the top and bottom, an excess of sweetness detracted from the overall experience. The cookie lacked the chocolate and caramel essence found in authentic Samoas, with a dry and brittle center that failed to capture the true essence of the original treat.
» …
rnrn