A guide to hosting — or showing up to — the modern potluck without the awkwardness
Published
March 15, 2026 12:03PM (EDT)
Potluck (Nicole Kandi)
When I hear the word potluck, I am transported, with a kind of olfactory immediacy, to the basement of my grandmother’s church. It smelled faintly damp — a mingling of industrial carpet cleaner and coffee that had been sitting on a warming plate too long. Curiously, I don’t remember the food itself in any particular detail. This is unusual for me. My memory for pleasurable meals is normally quite precise; I can recall a great pasta or a particularly good kiss with disconcerting clarity. But the potlucks of my childhood blur together into a kind of beige collective memory.
What remains instead are the categories. Aluminum trays of pasta bakes: lasagna, baked spaghetti, manicotti, stuffed shells. Big bowls of iceberg lettuce dressed in Italian vinaigrette. Brownies and bars cut into careful squares. Woven baskets filled with Parker House rolls or Hawaiian rolls. Tables that seemed to sag gently under the weight of carbohydrates.
The atmosphere, however, I remember well. The swish of polyester skirts in spring pastels — lavender, mint, butter-yellow — as the women of the church organized the spread. A few older veterans stepping outside to the parking lot for a cigarette, gazing across the cracked asphalt while someone inside reserved them a plate. A soft-faced teenage boy with flaxen hair playing the upright piano while a small orbit of youth-group girls gathered nearby.
The food was not intended to be memorable. That was not its purpose. The potluck functioned primarily as a social technology — a practical, edible reason for people to linger together after the service. Food was simply the mechanism that made the gathering possible.
I do not particularly miss the churches in which I was raised. But I find that I miss, unexpectedly, the culture of the potluck hangout: the casual gathering built around the modest premise that everyone brings something and the group shares.
Lately, though, I have found myself wondering about a small variation on this idea.
What if the food at a potluck was actually good?
Not elaborate, exactly. Just thoughtful. Imagine a table where someone arrives with a bubbling hot dip — something clearly intended for communal scooping, but which also suggests that someone, somewhere, chopped herbs, zested a lemon, and stirred the whole thing together in their kitchen beforehand. Or a guest who stops at the neighborhood bakery for excellent pita instead of grabbing the plastic-bagged version from the grocery store on the way over.
Potlucks, after all, are a form. And like most forms — poetry, cocktails, flirtation — they work best when people engage with them.
Want more great food writing and recipes? Sign up for Salon’s free food newsletter, The Bite.
When nobody does,